BSC Portrait Book: Claudia's Book
Like the other girls,
Claudia has to write her autobiography for school. After talking to
Stacey on the phone about math and thinking about her latest art
project, she sits down and talks with Janine. Her sister remembers
the day they brought Claudia home from the hospital and how she
looked, which surprises Claudia. She then sits down and actually
starts writing.
Her first real memory is
seeing a construction crew pour fresh concrete on the sidewalk. She,
Kristy, and Mary Anne drew in the wet concrete and thought it was
super cool until Mimi caught them. After giving them a short lecture
on how wrong it was, she makes a call and gets the crew back to pour
new concrete. Mimi then lets them put their hand prints in the
concrete. Way to teach them a lesson.
The girls are then in
school. Since her birthday comes during the summer, her mom gives her
invitations to hand out on the last day of school. Claudia is super
into circuses and throws a circus themed party with a lion tamer cake
and all that jazz but no one shows up. They figure that some kids
were too excited about the last day of school to show their parents
invitations and that others never got one. Claudia runs to her room
and cries a whole lot, but they all surprise her with a party anyway.
The whole Thomas family and Mary Anne's dad show up. They all bring
her gifts, which are actually things from their own homes that they
wrapped. She says it was her favorite birthday ever.
Later on all the kids are
super excited about the Tooth Fairy and how she leaves them money.
Mary Anne just hopes she gets enough to buy a new Barbie outfit.
Claudia somehow gets it in her mind that the Tooth Fairy actually
steals teeth right out of the mouths of kids and that she's some evil
monster. She decides that she will never, ever lose any of her teeth.
At the same time, her
teacher launches a project on dental hygiene. Her group makes a big
replica of a walrus tusk and even figures out how to make it look
slightly brown because you know that she's an expert at all things
art. On the way home from school, she trips and hits her mouth, which
loosens her tooth. Though she tries to ignore it, her parents find
out and schedule an appointment with a dentist.
The dentist looks at her
for about three seconds and finds out that she has an adult tooth
coming in behind it and the baby tooth needs to come out. They
schedule another appointment, and Claudia decides that if the dentist
keeps the tooth, she won't have to worry about the Tooth Fairy coming
to her house. Unfortunately, the dentist gives her back her tooth.
She spends all night worrying until her mom comes in and makes her
realize her mom is the Tooth Fairy. She then has a sudden realization
that her parents are also Santa, the Easter Bunny, and the whole nine
yards but decides not to ruin it for her friends.
Cut to a few years later
and her doing really bad in her classes. Her parents sit her down and
tell her that her teacher recommended she take some tests for
learning disabilities or possibly attend a specialized school. They
decide that sending her to some fancy pants school in Stanford, but
she waits until the last possibly second before telling her friends
and she even tries to fail the tests to get into the school.
One girl tries to become
friends with her and talk to her, but Claudia acts really mean and
snarky until she goes away. She mopes and whines the whole time,
stops eating junk food, and acts like a big brat. After her parents
make it clear that she isn't leaving the school, she stops doing art
and stops paying attention in class. Her parents finally decide to
let her go back to Stoneybrook anyway.
Claudia also gets upset
while at that school because SES is planning a special day where each
class does a project on a book character. Kristy and Mary Anne keep
talking about how much fun it is and she hates it. She eventually
stops calling them or going over to their houses and whines that they
never call her. Kristy does, but once they hang out again, she
pitches a fit because them talking about the project makes her sad.
The last story takes
place at some hotel and random beach. Sam and Charlie are playing in
a bunch of baseball games, and Mrs. Thomas lets Kristy bring along a
friend and she takes Claudia. They get left in charge of David
Michael for the day and have fun playing on the beach and hanging out
together. The next time they sit for him, he disappears and they
later find him playing with some kids. It's seriously like five pages
of them flipping out before finding him safe.
While at the games, David
Michael gets bored and Claudia offers to walk him around the field.
She watches him a second time during the championship. Claudia thinks
back on it and how it was basically her first sitting job and thinks
about how she was so impressed with Kristy taking charge when her
little brother went missing. Her teacher gives her an A+ for content
but a B- grade overall because of all her spelling and grammar
mistakes.
*Claudia comes across as
a little bitchy when talking with Janine. Janine says that she was
eating alphabet soup and found all the letters except for a few,
which makes Claudia roll her eyes at how dorky her sister is. I
actually like her a little more than Claudia most of the time.
*Her birthday outfit was
black tights, a tee shirts with a lion on it, high black boots, and a
red jacket with gold buckles on it. I really hope the ghostwriter
meant leggings and not tights because no 5-6 year old should run
around wearing only tights and a tee shirt.
*The Thomas family gives
her Sam and Charlie's old train set, which she says she later gave to
David Michael for his birthday. It was actually kind of cute.
*So Claudia goes to her
family dentist who then refers her to another dentist to actually
pull the tooth. What the hell, isn't that what a dentist does? When I
was a kid and had an adult tooth pushing out a baby tooth, we went to
our family dentist and he took it out that same day. They send
Claudia to some "special" dentist the day after her
appointment with the family dentist.
*I love that the
ghostwriter sticks with the whole Claudia is oh so mature thing that
she figures out the Tooth Fairy/Santa/etc. thing before anyone else
in her class. God forbid she ever just act like a kid.
*Claudia literally says
that she'll stop talking to her friends when she goes to her new
school to see how long it takes for them to notice. Kristy calls her
on the third day, which she acts like proves her point but come on,
it wasn't even three whole days.
*The whole alternative
school storyline really pissed me off. Claudia was doing so bad at
SES that she was in danger of failing/being held back. The new school
has super small classes and focuses on individualized learning, so
teachers can really help her. She spends a few weeks pouting and
acting like a huge baby, so they give up and send her back to a
school that can't help her at all. I wonder how much money they lost
on her tuition.
*It seems like the big
reason they let her go back is because she says she doesn't want to
do art anymore or be an artist. Yeah, you're right. Kids always grow
up to do exactly what they wanted to do when they were eight.
*There's another mention
in this book about how she doesn't have a learning disability. I'm
sorry but the way they write her and show her in school, she has all
the signs of a learning disability. Instead they just play it off as
she's way too artistic to be smart or do good in school.
*Claudia plans a collage
for her special school of a model's head, random clothes, and a
perfume sample. She says she was so unhappy that the finished project
just looked like random things thrown on paper. Um, isn't that what a
collage is?
Claudia really is a jerk to Janine, it amazes me how we're suppose to side with Claudia and thinking Janine's the mean one but really its Claudia. She's the one constantly making fun of or putting down everything her sister does. Janine has always tried to show an interest in what Claudia likes, encouraged her and defended her when she was accused of cheating.
ReplyDeleteI know for the timeline Claudia eventually had to go back to SES but she would have done much better at the other school. She has been shown to do really well when she has help and goes at a slower pace.
I thought the same thing when Claudia went back to the 7th grade she was finally starting to really learn and do good, then of course gets asked if she wants to go back Maybe her parents should make decisions based on what's better for her in the long run.
I never liked the last story it felt out of place in Claudia's story. Was there really no other story for Claudia to tell? How about the Kishis on a trip? Or another story with Claudia and Mimi? Or something?
I liked learning Claudia loved the circus.
The last story had to be in there so we would remember that she's a babysitter! I think they all had at least one sitting story, but I don't have Abby's book...
DeleteIt really bugs me that we constantly get told that she doesn't have a learning disability, when she clearly does. You don't get sent to a special school or get sent back a grade just because you don't really pay attention in school!
I'm trying to remember if the others had a sitting story. Dawn's had the fire, Mary Anne's only mentioned sitting in Iowa and what happened. I can't remember one in Kristy's.
DeleteI agree about the disability. There's no way you'd do all those things for a kid unless they had a problem. There's no way with all of the signs that Claudia doesn't have a problem. Not only does she have a problem. The only time she does well is at the special school or when she's sent back to the 7th grade.